How We Review Home Security Companies

How We Review Home Security Companies

We believe that home security is best approached in layers. One layer crucial to total home security is a home security system. In general, most companies are alike when it comes to the equipment they use to protect your home. In fact, many major companies choose equipment from GE or Honeywell and services from vendors like So how can you determine who is the best when so much is the same?

We’ve decided to review home security companies using three primary categories: protection and equipment, home automation, and customer service. Scores from each of the three categories are averaged together to award a total score.


Protection and equipment encompasses seven checkpoints that take into consideration what the company provides from an equipment and monitoring perspective and also how they price their service. For example, a company that charges thousands of dollars for a basic equipment package isn’t going to score as high as a company that provides basic equipment for free.


Home automation is a vital component of any modern home security system. And for this category, we use a ten point checklist. Though you may not be interested in a smart home now, you might be in the future. We want to make sure you are buying a system that is future proof. And if you are buying a smart home system, we want to ensure it is a system that can deliver light automation, small appliance control, temperature control, and lock automation. Within the home automation category, we also look for the ability to add both indoor and outdoor security cameras as well as the ability to connect to other third-party devices. Finally, we dig into mobile app performance including available platforms and user reviews.


The final piece of the pie: customer service. When reviewing a company’s ability to provide service, we start with their BBB score. Over the years, we’ve learned that it is a telling indicator but doesn’t tell all. We’ve found that what really matters is a company’s willingness to employ customer-friendly policies. We look at the company’s minimum contract length, their return period, moving policy, renewal policy, and more. This category also takes into consideration reviews and feedback we get from readers as well as any hands-on experience we may have.


Samuel Cook
Senior Associate Editor
Samuel Cook lives in Virginia with his wife and son. He writes about home security, security cameras, and smart homes. As he is a former English teacher, he also proofreads many of our articles.
Bethuel Cruz
Senior Associate Editor
Bethuel Cruz writes about smart homes, robotics, and crowdfunding campaigns. In his free time, he volunteers at a local animal shelter. He’s also a self-described “car geek” and an avid coffee drinker.

Rose Thibodeaux
Rose has worked in the technology and security industry since 2003. She has attended multiple CES shows, has her own security/smart home focused YouTube channel, and has hands-on experience with dozens of smart home and home security products.

Researching home security companies is not an easy task. It’s a continuous process. It’s talking to homeowners, testing the equipment, visiting trade shows, scouring websites, and occasionally it involves going undercover (secret shopping). Using the aggregated score from the three categories above, we rank the companies from best to last, but the list is ever changing. As companies improve (or deteriorate), we revisit our appraisal. Over the years, we’ve been able to create a factual database, and we strive to “tell it like it is,” glitches and all. ~ Rose

Currently, we have hands-on experience with several of our nationally ranked companies including Frontpoint, Link, Armorax, LivSecure, SimpliSafe, Ring Alarm, abode, Nest Secure, GetSafe, and more, as well as experiences with Vivint, ADT, and XFINITY via CES.

Feel free to contact us should you have any questions.