Comparing Abode to Scout and SimplisafeBy - 03/20/2017
abode rolled out during a period where self-monitored home security systems were a dime a dozen. They just barely made their Kickstarter goal, but as promised, they’ve delivered a product to backers. Two years later, abode is one of the few self-monitored startups that appears to be going strong. So what is it about abode that makes it both unique and successful?
What is abode?
abode is a home security system that can either be self-monitored or professionally monitored 24/7 for a price.. Unlike other monitoring companies, abode does not require a contract. In fact, you can choose to have your system monitored for a few days or a week versus the typical month-to-month option. In addition to home security, abode provides smart home integration through relationships with other connected devices and services. What you can do with the product will depend on what package you choose. Currently, they offer three packages: Basic, Connect, and Connect + Secure.
|BASIC||CONNECT||CONNECT + SECURE|
|Price||$0||$10/month or $96/year||$30/month or $240/year|
|iOS, Android, and Web App Control|
|3G Cellular Backup|
|24/7 Professional Monitoring||Optional On-Demand Professional
Monitoring (3 Days: $8 / 7 Days: $15)
|Timeline and Media Storage||3 Days||14 Days||90 Days|
|Unlimited User Accounts|
|IFTTT, Amazon Echo, Works with Nest|
|Customer Support||Email and Support Site||Phone, Email, and Support Site||Premium Phone, Email, and Support Site|
While abode can connect to other smart home and home security devices, it can also protect your home on its own using six wireless abode-branded devices. All of abode’s devices are wireless and can be self-installed in minutes.
For abode, everything starts with the Gateway, a Z-Wave, Zigbee, and WiFi-enabled hub/controller. The Gateway communicates with your connected sensors using a proprietary protocol called abodeRF. The protocol encrypts communication between the Gateway and your devices as well as communication between the Gateway and the cloud. When your Gateway receives information from your connected devices, it then sends the information to the cloud, your app, or the central monitoring center depending on what event has occurred and how you’ve previously asked it to respond. In addition to handling communication, the Gateway will keep you up and running thanks to battery backup (10 hours) and a cellular chip. It even has an integrated 95db siren.
The abode Gateway can support up to 150 connected devices and up to six IP Streaming Cameras. After using the Gateway (thanks to abode who generously allowed me to test their system for free), I found that there are both pros and cons.
- Works as Intended
- Battery Backup Worked and Notification Received When System Lost Power
- Requires Ethernet
- Small LED Light Indicates System Status
abode Sensors and Keypad
The second device abode offers is the Door/Window Contact. The contact sensors will monitor doors, cabinets, windows, or anything that opens and closes. abode even promises that the sensors will run on battery for 10+ years.
Third, abode sells a Wireless Keypad. The keypad supports 40 unique codes, includes a backlit interface, and has a battery life of 4-6 years. The keypad includes three LEDS that will indicate if the system is armed, disarmed, or armed home. To conserve battery life, the lights are not always on. Instead, you will need to press a button on the keypad to light up the display.
Fourth, abode sells a Key Fob. Using the Key Fob, you can arm and disarm your system with a click.
- All Devices Worked as Intended (Keypad Not Tested)
- Easy Installation
- Sensors are Clunky, Cheap Feeling
Finally, abode sells a Motion Camera and a Streaming Camera to round out their list of devices.
abode’s Motion Camera is an image sensor. It’s a pet-immune (pets under 60lbs) motion sensor with a camera. If it senses movement, it will snap a photo and send it to you for visual verification. As motion detectors are a common cause of false alarms, being able to visually identify if an alert is real or not is essential, and abode is the only self-monitored home security system offering this technology.
Like most image sensors, the Motion Camera is low-definition (640x480p). However, at close range, the image quality is sufficient. When an event is detected, it takes three photographs and sends them to your timeline with a copy sent via email. The email includes the actual photograph so that you can quickly glance to determine if an event is real or not.
- Takes Three Consecutive Photographs
- Sends Snapshot to Email and Timeline
- Clunky, Cheap Feeling
- Low Resolution
The Streaming Camera is a traditional home security camera. The camera uses WiFi or an Ethernet connection and offers live streaming in 720p HD, IR LEDs for night vision, and a wide angle field of view. When an event is detected, the Streaming Camera records to the cloud or you can add a microSD card to store footage locally as well.
The Streaming Camera is not my favorite security camera. First of all, motion detection with this device is confusing. Without a MicroSD card, it relies on other sensors to trigger event recordings, or it will record when a rule is triggered. For example, you can set a rule that says, “record a video clip when the front door opens”. With a MicroSD card, the camera will record video when motion is detected; however, it cannot activate the alarm siren nor will you receive a notification when an event is detected, making the feature rather useless. Alternatively, you can request clips on-demand from the mobile app.
The second reason I’m not a Streaming Camera fan is that it doesn’t record sound. The abode team assures me that if you choose to add a microSD card to the camera, it will record sound with clips. My camera, however, did not. Also, in order to view clips with sound, you will need to remove the microSD card from the camera and insert it into a computer. The third reason I’m not a fan is that you can’t download clips locally from the app. You can only save clips using the microSD card. Fourth, the video quality is just okay. In the YouTube video below, you can compare footage from SimpliSafe’s camera to abode’s at minute 1:55. Both cameras record in 720p, but SimpliSafe’s picture is clearer. On that note, abode’s night vision quality appears to be superior. Fifth, you can’t control any of the camera’s settings. Finally, I’m not a fan of the boxy design.
Fortunately, it’s not all doom and gloom with the Streaming Camera. For free, abode provides three days of cloud storage for video events. You can view these events with or without the added microSD card, and you can view them from the web portal or the mobile app. Also, the camera effectively captures pre-event footage. It records 2 seconds pre-alarm and 8 seconds post.
- Free Cloud Storage
- Option for Local Storage
- Pre-Event Recording
- Optional Wall Mount
- Motion Detection Confusing
- Sound Recording Has Issues
- Clunky Design
If you want to expand beyond abode-branded devices, you have several options including Nest, IFTTT, Zigbee, Z-Wave, and Amazon Alexa. Through integration, you can control all of your devices with one app and create rules that are made even more intelligent via abode’s native geofencing feature. For example, when all of your family members are away from home, you can set a reminder to arm your abode system, set your Cree lights to turn off, and your Nest thermostat to adjust accordingly.
Works with Nest
Through Works with Nest, abode integrates with the Nest Protect, Nest Thermostat, and Nest Cam. You can choose to integrate with all of your Nest devices or limit abode to specific Nest devices. You also have the option to allow abode to sync with your Nest modes or keep them separate. If you decide to sync modes, abode will trigger Nest to Away Mode when abode is in Away Mode or tell Nest to change to Home Mode when abode is in Home or Standby Mode.
Nest Cam and Cloud Storage
If you choose to integrate abode with Nest Cam, it will not replace Nest Aware, Nest’s cloud recording service. What it can do will depend on your Nest Aware subscription as well as your abode subscription. As it appears that abode actually expands upon Nest’s included storage, I wanted to be very clear about the offer. After several emails and a phone call with the abode team, this is what I learned.
|No Nest Plan||Nest Aware 10 Day||Nest Aware 30 Day|
|Without Abode||$0 / 3 Hours Snapshots via Nest||$10 / 10 Days via Nest||$30 / 30 Days via Nest|
|Abode Basic||$0 / 3 Days of Snapshots via Abode||$10 / 10 Days via Nest and Abode||$30 / 10 Days via Abode or 30 via Nest|
|Abode CONNECT||$10 / 10 Days of Snapshots via Abode||$20 / 10 Days via Nest and Abode||$40 / 10 Days via Abode or 30 via Nest|
|Abode CONNECT + SECURE||$30 / 10 Days of Snapshots via Abode||$40 / 10 Days via Nest and Abode||$60 / 10 Days via Abode or 30 via Nest|
|Prices are per month, Nest provides a discount for additional cameras.|
According to abode,
For all abode/Nest integrations, regardless of whether or not the customer has a Nest Aware plan, abode stores Nest Cam Snapshots in the timeline for a maximum of 10 days. If the user is on the abode Basic plan, those snapshots are deleted after 3 days. If the user is on the Connect or Connect + Secure plan, the snapshots are deleted after 10 days per Nest TOS. Customers without a Nest Aware plan can only capture 2 snapshots per minutes whereas customers with Nest Aware plan can have 10 snapshots per minute.
As you can see, there are pros and cons to using abode to monitor your Nest Cam. For free, Nest only offers 3 hours of snapshot storage, so adding an abode system provides more storage. Another pro to using abode with Nest is that you can use people as a trigger for events. When choosing your event type, you can opt to see motion, people, or sound events within your timeline. The integration also works with modes and zones. For example, you can set up a rule that only records people events that occur on your porch to your abode timeline.
The downside is that even if you are a Nest Aware subscriber, abode only stores snapshots (a.k.a a picture). When an alarm event is detected, abode will automatically trigger your Nest Cam to record. A snapshot will be logged to your timeline, and you will receive a notice via email as well as a push notification. Unfortunately, the email does not include the snapshot. Rather, it lets you know that one is available and provides a link to your abode timeline.
Fortunately, you can always navigate over to Nest.com to view your full video history. And if you are subscribed to the Nest Aware 30 day plan, you will also need to navigate over to see anything recorded beyond the included 10-day history.
abode also has its own IFTTT channel. IFTTT connects internet connected services and devices using applets in an “if this then that” format. abode’s channel provides both Triggers (the if) and Actions (the then). As a Trigger, abode can request another device to take action if an alarm is activated, if you change the mode, if a door is opened/closed, if a door is locked/unlocked, if a garage door is opened/closed, or if a switch is on/off. If you prefer another device to be the trigger, abode can take the following actions: change mode, turn a switch on/off, toggle switch, change dimmer level, lock/unlock, close/open garage door, or quick action. For example, IFTTT can call your phone if abode’s alarm is triggered or flash your Hue bulbs if your front door is opened.
Z-Wave and Zigbee
The third integration is provided through the abode Gateway’s integrated protocols. abode maintains a list of devices that are compatible with their system thanks to Z-Wave & Zigbee. The list includes devices from makers like Aeon, Cree, Enerwave, GE, Kiwkset, Linear, Philips Hue, Schlagle, and Netvox.
Finally, though you can connect Amazon Echo and abode using IFTTT, you can also integrate the two directly using an Alexa skill. You can ask Alexa to retrieve abode’s system status, mode, to arm abode, disarm it, trigger panic mode, call the police (assuming you using CONNECT + SECURE), trigger a fire alarm, check the status of your doors, windows, lock your doors, unlock them, etc. As an added security measure, you must provide a verbal PIN code to disarm your abode system or to unlock your doors using Amazon Alexa.
Regarding functionality, abode’s Alexa skill is vastly superior to most integrations between home security systems and Alexa. It also appears to be superior in regards to user feedback. The skill is currently rated 4 stars where similar skills are rated 2 stars. In testing, the skill worked flawlessly.
abode vs. SimpliSafe vs. Scout
As a security system, abode is most comparable to Scout, though it’s often compared to SimpliSafe. Like Scout and SimpliSafe, abode is a self-monitored home security system with the option for professional monitoring. Ironically, they all three use COPS monitoring services, though abode also uses UCC. They all three use a cellular signal for monitoring though abode technically uses Ethernet with a cellular backup.
What sets abode apart from SimpliSafe is that it’s smart home ready as it’s equipped with Z-Wave, ZigBee, and other automation features. What sets it apart from Scout is that abode offers home automation features, including IFTTT, for free and they provide improved usability through devices like their keypad and image sensor. What sets abode apart from both SimpliSafe and Scout is that as a free, self-monitored system it provides actual security value.
Self-Monitored, No Fee Plans Compared
|Home Automation Features Included|
|Amazon Echo Integration|
|Works with Nest|
|Security Camera Integration||3 Days of Timeline and Media Access|
|Where to Buy||Visit Site||Visit Site||Visit Site|
Paid Plans Compared
Another feature that sets abode apart is that you can add a no contract monthly plan for professional monitoring or you can add on-demand professional monitoring. For $8, you can pay for three days of monitoring, perfect for weekend trips. Or for $15 you can add seven days of professional monitoring. If you prefer to pay per month, they have two plans to cover you: Connect and Connect + Secure.
|Plans||CONNECT||CONNECT + SECURE
||Always On||Always On +||Standard||Interactive|
|24/7 Alarm Monitoring|
|UL Certified monitoring|
|Plans||CONNECT||CONNECT + SECURE
||Always On||Always On +||Standard||Interactive|
|Cellular Connection / 3G|
|Contract||Not Required||Not Required||Not Required|
|Android and iPhone App|
|Home Automation||Nest Thermostat|
|Amazon Echo & IFTTT Access|
|Indoor Security Camera||Abode Camera & Limited Integration With Nest Cam||Limited Integration With Nest Cam|
|Outdoor Security Camera||Limited Integration With Nest Cam||Limited Integration With Nest Cam|
|Recorded Video History||Included||Via Nest Aware||$4.99/month|
|Return Policy||14 Day Return Policy||30 days minus a 10% restocking fee||60 Day|
|Product Warranty||1 Year Limited||1 Year Limited||3 Year|
|Where to Buy||Visit Site||Visit Site||Visit Site|
*Scout offers a 10% discount if you pay annually. abode offers an even greater discount. Connect is $96 per year, Connect + Secure is $240,
Equipment Costs Compared
All three systems start with a base station. SimpliSafe’s base station works hand-in-hand with a keypad where abode’s keypad is sold separately, and Scout doesn’t offer one at all. In some ways, this is an advantage for SimpliSafe, but unfortunately, the keypad is anything but user-friendly. In fact, all three systems share one disadvantage: lack of visual reference. With abode, the base station has one tiny light that swaps between red, flashing red, and off to indicate if the system is armed or disarmed. SimpliSafe relies on the keypad to convey information, and Scout uses an LED light which swaps between white, purple, and black. But to make things more confusing, Scout’s color systems means one thing if seen on the base station and another if seen on the door panel.
With the base stations in place, you can build your security system by adding sensors. All three companies offer kits, packages which include the base station and multiple pre-selected sensors. In fact, with abode, a starter kit is required. However, you can add equipment a la carte until you have what you need to protect your home. The below chart outlines sensor cost if purchased outside of a kit.
|System Status Indicator||$36.00|
|Temperature, Humidity, & Light Sensor||$49.00|
|Extra Keychain Remote||$27.00||$4.99||$24.99|
|Extra Siren||$59.00 (95dB)||$59.99 (105dB)|
|Extra Keypad||$79.00||$69.00 (Door Panel)||$69.99|
|Extra Entry Magnet||$4.99|
|Home Automation Power Outlet & ZigBee Extender||$49.00|
On paper, abode appeared to be superior to both SimpliSafe and Scout. After testing, I feel the same way. (In addition to testing abode, I have tested both SimpliSafe and Scout. You can read about my experience here.)
What disappointed me the most about abode was the feel of the hardware. Though abode looks cool on the web, it feels cheap and clunky in person, and the camera concept is a miss. However, they offer all of the free services they promise, their geofencing feature is the most accurate I’ve ever tested, their customer service/tech support is out of this world stellar, the integrations improve home security, and the system works. In my opinion, the pros outweigh the cons.
abode suggests you get started with the appropriately named starter kit. The kit includes a hub, motion-detecting camera, door/window sensors, an indoor WiFi camera, and a key fob for $350.
3/20/2017 updated with hands-on abode experience