Arlo Pro vs. Arlo Pro 2 Home Security CamerasBy - 04/30/2018
I’ve been running Arlo Pro for a while, and I like it. In fact, even after testing Blink, Blink XT, Reolink Argus, and Canary Flex, it remains my favorite battery-powered home security camera. So when Netgear asked if I would be interested in testing Arlo Pro 2, it was a no-brainer. Running the two cameras side-by-side I’ve learned that while there aren’t a lot of differences between the two devices there are a few worth mentioning.
Arlo Wire-Free vs. Arlo Pro vs. Arlo Pro 2
Arlo sells three, wire-free security cameras. I only have hands-on experience with Pro and Pro 2 but I’m familiar with Arlo Wire-Free. As Netgear is still selling it, I thought a comparison of all three cameras might be helpful.
|Arlo Wire-Free||Arlo Pro||Arlo Pro 2|
|Add-On Camera Cost||$129.68||$169.99||$219.99|
|Field of View||110°||130°||130°|
|Motion Detection||Yes||Yes, PIR||Yes, PIR|
|Power Option||Battery||Battery, Indoor AC Power Included, Outdoor AC Power Sold Separately||Battery, Indoor AC Power Included, Outdoor AC Power Sold Separately|
|Place or Mount||Place or Use Magnetic Mount||Place or Use Magnetic Mount||Place or Use Magnetic Mount|
|Compatible Base Station||Original and Pro 2||Original and Pro 2||Original and Pro 2|
|Free Cloud Storage|
|Additional Features||If Plugged-In: Look Back, Activity Zones, and CVR|
All three camera systems rely on a base station, which remains connected to Ethernet and power, but the cameras are cordless and communicate with the base station using a wireless protocol.
I often get asked about camera range. As in, how far away from the base station can you place a camera? And while I could answer that question as it relates to my experience, the answer would not be the same for you. The maximum distance you can place Arlo from the base station is 300 feet, but that distance is affected by several variables including building material, walls, doors, and more.
Aesthetics and Arlo Accessory Compatibility
I read several reviews and forums before testing Pro 2. Many indicated that the camera is physically different than its predecessor. It’s not. The size difference is an optical illusion caused by the color of the camera’s ring. Arlo Pro 2 has a white ring where Arlo Pro has a black ring, which makes the camera look bigger, even though it’s not. The only other physical difference is letter coloring. Arlo Pro 2’s lettering is metallic, where Arlo Pro’s lettering is flat.
As the cameras are the same size, they use the same accessories including outdoor power adapters, skins, batteries, solar panels, and mounts. They are both managed by the Arlo app which means that you can control all of your Arlo cameras (Arlo Baby, the original Arlo Wire-Free, Arlo Pro, Arlo Pro 2, Arlo Security Light, Arlo Go, and Arlo Q) from the same place. They also work with the same base station. In fact, if you purchase Arlo Pro 2 as a Starter Kit (Base Station and Cameras included), it will ship with the Arlo Pro Base Station, which is the same Base Station that ships with Arlo Pro. The cameras are also backward compatible with the original Base Station, though there are advantages to buying the Pro version (USB Storage and a built-in siren).
Arlo Pro, Pro 2, and Arlo Wire-Free will also be compatible with Arlo Audio Doorbell once it launches. The Arlo Audio Doorbell is a smart doorbell that lets you answer your door from anywhere. But unlike video doorbells, the Audio Doorbell isn’t equipped with a camera. So if you want to see your guests and monitor your front door, you’ll need to pair the doorbell with one of Arlo’s wireless cameras.
Arlo Pro and Arlo Pro 2 Security Features
Arlo Pro and Pro 2 both have motion and sound detectors. Out of the box, you can configure both detectors using Modes and Rules, but they share other security features as well.
Modes and Rules
The app includes four starter modes: armed, disarmed, schedule, and geofencing. Of the four, only disarmed can’t be customized. The other modes can be customized on multiple levels. For example, armed mode allows you to customize settings for each of your cameras connected to your base station. Using different Rules, which are like Mode subcategories, you might have an outdoor camera set to detect motion and record video where your indoor camera only detects audio and sounds the siren when an event occurs.
Under each camera, you can create your own “If This Then That” flow. Under If This, you can choose from if motion is detected, if audio is detected, or both. You can dig in deeper by adjusting the sensitivity level of both the motion and audio sensor. Under Then That, you can choose between do nothing and recording video, you can also choose to trigger the siren. You can adjust the recording length to be anywhere between 10 and 120 seconds, or you can let the camera record until activity stops (maximum of 300 seconds) though I’ve found the latter option to be a bit buggy. The siren duration can also be customized (60-300 seconds), and you can adjust the siren’s loudness. Finally, you can choose how the system should alert you. It can send push notifications, email alerts, or both.
Another option is to create schedules. Schedules are configured by day and by the hour. For example, you can say on Tuesdays and Thursdays, arm the cameras between 8 am and 5 pm. You can choose from three modes when creating a schedule: armed, disarmed, or your own custom mode.
Sometimes creating your own mode is best, which is where custom modes come into play. Custom modes support multiple Rules so that your system behaves how you want it to behave using the same “If This Then That” scenarios described above. For example, you can arm your outdoor cameras, while leaving your indoor cameras disarmed.
Finally, Geofencing. Geofencing is my favorite mode, but it’s not perfect. Within the app, you will create a virtual fence around your home. When you leave the fenced area, your system will automatically arm. When you return, your cameras will automatically disarm. The downside is that Geofencing doesn’t always work. The system consistently arms when I leave, but it doesn’t always disarm when I return. Often, I have to open the app to signify my presence.
The customization options available within the Geofencing option are slightly different. Instead of using Rules, it uses other Modes. You can select a Mode that should run while you’re Away and another for when you are Home. For example, I have it set to where it arms all of my indoor and outdoor cameras when I leave, but when I return home, it only disarms my inside cameras as I want my outdoor cameras always armed. (Directions for setting this up found here.) This type of configuration is possible as it uses armed mode when I’m away and a custom mode when I’m home.
Friends and Family
Arlo is a self-monitored security system, but you don’t have to go at it alone. You can add other users. Other users will have their own login and password. They can view live streams as well as recorded clips from your Arlo Library. You can choose to limit their access to monitoring, or you expand it to include limited administrative rights like the ability to select modes and delete clips from the library.
Friends and Family can also affect how your system behaves when using the Geofencing Mode. When you add other devices to your system, the system will arm when the last devices have left your pre-defined area and will disarm when at least one device returns. You can even include or exclude users as you see fit. From the mobile app, click Mode, click the pencil icon next to Geofencing, click Enabled Devices, and then select the devices you want to use for Geofencing. Next to each device, you will also see if the device is In Zone (Home) or Out of Zone (Away).
Both cameras also share the ability to customize settings using the mobile app. From the app, you can turn the camera on or off, check its battery level, run a motion detection test (LED will flash to show you when motion is detected) and configure audio and video settings.
- Turn Night Vision On/Off
- Rotate Image 180°
- Pan, Zoom, Reset, and Snapshot
- Power Management (Best Video, Optimized, Best Battery Life)
- Turn Microphone On/Off
- Turn Speaker On/Off
- Adjust Speaker Volume
Cloud and Local Storage
Finally, one of the most significant security features offered by Netgear is free cloud and local storage.
If you connect the cameras to the Pro Base Station, you will also have access to local storage via a USB storage device (flash drive, hard drive). When using local storage, your cameras will record to the cloud and the local device simultaneously. Local storage acts as a backup to the cloud, not as a primary storage method. However, local storage will take over if you lose your internet connection. Of course, this assumes that the base station still has access to power. The storage device you choose must use a FAT32 file system format. FAT32 supports up to 2TB.
Both Arlo Pro and Arlo Pro 2 include seven days of cloud storage (1GB) for motion and sound events. The free plan is called Basic. Basic supports up to five cameras and provides three months of tech support. All recorded clips are saved to your library.
From the library, you can favorite, download, donate, share, and delete clips in bulk or individually. You can also filter footage. You can filter by camera, favorites, non-favorites, motion events, audio events, manual recordings, or you can filter to view only events triggered by IFTTT.
Paid Storage and Arlo Smart
If you add Arlo Smart, you can also filter down to view only person events as Arlo Smart adds Person Detection. For $2.99 per month per camera, you can add Arlo Smart and retain access to Arlo’s generous cloud storage offer. Paying for Arlo Smart also adds Rich Notifications and Activity Zones for all cameras.
In addition to paying a la carte for Arlo Smart, you can gain access to all Arlo Smart features plus e911 by paying for one of Arlo’s paid cloud plans.
The first paid plan is Premier. For $9.99 per month or $99.00 per year, you can add up to ten cameras, have access to unlimited support, Arlo Smart, e911, and thirty days of cloud recordings (10GB storage). The second paid plan is Elite. Elite supports up to fifteen cameras and offers sixty days of cloud recording (100GB storage) for $14.99 per month or $149.00 per year. All stored videos can be downloaded to your phone from the mobile app or to your computer from the web app.
Finally, you can add continuous video recording (CVR), but this is a feature exclusive to Arlo Pro 2.
Additional Arlo Pro 2 Security Features
When it comes down to it, there are really only five differences between Pro and Pro 2. The first is price. The second is resolution. During the day, Pro 2 offers a FHD picture where Pro is HD.
As you can see, the difference is really in the details. The blades of grass are much more defined when viewing both live and recorded footage, but the difference isn’t huge. If you want to view a more detailed comparison of resolution, check out the footage starting at minute 1:33.
Besides resolution, all other features that are exclusive to Arlo Pro 2 require that the camera is plugged in. But take note: the included power cord is not weatherproof. If you want to keep the camera plugged in outdoors, you will need to purchase the Outdoor Power Adapter (VMA4900, $24.99), which works with both Arlo Pro and Arlo Pro 2.
The first plugged-in feature exclusive to Pro 2 is CVR (it also works with Arlo Q, Netgear’s wired indoor camera). When subscribed to a CVR plan, the cameras will record non-stop, 24/7. CVR plans are charged per camera rather than per account. The first plan provides fourteen days of continuous video for $9.99 per camera per month or $99.00 per year. The second plan provides thirty days of recordings for $19.99 per month per camera or $199.00 per year. If you want to add CVR to more than one camera, you will receive a 50% discount on each additional plan. Arlo does not support the ability to download CVR video.
The second plugged-in feature is called Activity Zones. Arlo Pro 2 can support up to three rectangular shaped Activity Zones. If motion is detected within your set zone, you’ll receive a notification. Activity that occurs outside of your set zones will be ignored. As Pro 2 offers a wide angle view, this is handy when monitoring large rooms. As an example, you can monitor your front door while ignoring walkways which would allow you to continue monitoring even when you’re home. As already mentioned, if you pay for Arlo Smart, you’ll also have access to Activity Zones even when the camera is unplugged.
Finally, while plugged-in, Arlo Pro 2 supports Look Back. Look Back tries to solve one of the major challenges of a battery powered security camera: sleepiness. To conserve battery life, most battery-powered cameras sleep between events. The problem is that sometimes events happen so quickly, that the camera can fail to capture footage that is helpful. Look Back allows the camera to buffer 3-seconds of footage constantly. If an event occurs, that 3-second buffer is tacked onto your video so that you have the event footage plus an extra three seconds, reducing the likelihood of a missed event.
In addition to integrating with its own products, services, and accessories, Netgear Arlo cameras work with third-party devices.
All three wire-free cameras (Arlo, Arlo Pro, and Arlo Pro 2) work with the Alexa Skill. The Alexa Skill is not compatible with all Alexa devices. Currently, it is only compatible with Alexa devices that have a screen including:
- Echo Show
- Echo Spot
- Fire TV, 2nd Gen Fire TV stick, and Fire TV Edition smart TVs
Using your voice, you can ask Alexa to show a live stream from any of your cameras. The feed will broadcast to your connected device.
Second, Arlo works with SmartThings. I have a separate article on the integration which you can check out here.
Third, Arlo can integrate with other third-party devices and services through IFTTT and Stringify. IFTTT works using Triggers and Actions. Arlo has three triggers and three available actions.
- Motion Detected (Trigger)
- Low Battery (Trigger)
- Audio Detected (Trigger)
- Arm (Action)
- Disarm (Action)
- Start Recording (Action)
Stringify works similarly but allows for more complex rules. For example, “If motion is detected, but only if it’s after 9 am, sound the siren, but not if my front door is open.”
Finally, the cameras work with Google Assistant. You can ask Google Assistant to live stream your cameras on your Chromecast, NVIDIA Shield TV, Android, or iOS devices.
For me, Arlo Pro 2 is working great. It does everything Netgear promised it would do including delivering a higher resolution. However, Netgear forums are rife with those who don’t agree with me. While I’m certainly not the only user who has had a good experience with Arlo Pro 2, not all users have been so lucky. Several users have reported that Arlo Pro 2 has issues including an issue where the camera goes offline, draining the battery when it comes back online. Netgear is currently working on a firmware update to resolve the issue. I tell you this because I want you to understand that Arlo Pro 2 is still a new device.
Arlo continues to be one of my favorite security cameras. Is Pro 2 worth the extra money? For me, yes. I don’t plan to use the camera plugged-in, so the only feature I can take advantage of is the higher resolution, but that’s important to me. The difference in resolution isn’t huge, so I would by no means say that Pro 2 is the hands-down winner when compared to Arlo Pro. In the end, it’s really up to you. Will you use the camera plugged-in? Is the resolution important to you?
Update: 4/30/2018: I ran Arlo Pro and Pro 2 side-by-side for 5 months to compare battery life. My hypothesis was that Arlo Pro would last longer than Pro 2 due to 2’s higher resolution. I was wrong. There was almost no difference between the two batteries though Arlo Pro 2 held a slightly better charge (1-5% at times) than Arlo Pro. I think this difference is probably due to the battery being newer than the one I have in my Arlo Pro. Final verdict: There is no difference in battery life. What seems to have the most impact on battery life is activity. In previous tests, Arlo Pro lasted about 2 months in a higher traffic area. The time to recharge the camera’s battery from 0-100% was 2 hours and 30 minutes.