Keeping Your Home Safe With Google HomeBy - 08/10/2017
Anyone who aims to go up against Amazon’s Alexa is going to have a tough fight on their hands. Nevertheless, if anyone can do it, Google can. Toe-to-toe, Google Home appears to be a worthy competitor, but when it comes to home security there’s still one question that remains:Can it protect your home as well as Echo can?
What Is Google Home?
Google Home is an internet-connected speaker with a virtual voice assistant. It can play music and podcasts from Google Play Music, Spotify Premium, YouTube Music, Pandora, iHeartRadio, and TuneIn using its high-excursion speaker. It can also stream music from your phone via phone mirroring, Bluetooth, or Chromecast-enabled apps. Google Home can also cast to your TV via Chromecast for access to Netflix and YouTube.
Google Home also functions as an assistant via Google Assistant, an evolved version of Google Now with the ability to engage in contextual conversations. For example, you can ask it about the weather today and follow up with, “What about tomorrow?”.
With your permission, the device can also “get to know you”, providing deeper customization. Using your location, your Google calendar, your search history, and any connected service or device (Android phones, Chromebook, YouTube, Nest, Gmail, etc.), it starts to piece together information about you. Combine this with Google’s search engine power, and you begin to realize that Google Home has the potential to be a valuable assistant. Though somewhat gimmicky, the device can even memorize your favorite song, color, person, etc. And as an added bonus, Google Home can do this for everyone in your house, not just you. The device supports six different user profiles and can learn to recognize voices so that it knows who is talking and whose account it should access. That said, during testing, Google Home did mix up similar voices. For example, Home Alarm Report’s Rose Thibodeaux’s voice was confused with her sister.
For those who are concerned that Google Bots are listening to everything you say, you might find some comfort in knowing that Google Home listens and even processes who is talking locally. It uploads information to the cloud when the wake word, “OK, Google” or “Hey, Google”, is spoken or when you long press the touch interface at the top of the device. To further protect your privacy, you can use Home’s lights as indicators. If voice control is on, the four dots on the top will light up red, blue, green, and yellow, indicating that it is ready to listen. If the lights are steady and red, it means the mic is off. You can also turn it on or off by pressing the mute button on the front of the device. Finally, though many are not a fan of saying Google’s required wake phrase, the longer phrase does allow for even greater privacy. Where Echo often wakes when it hears words that sound anything like Alexa, we haven’t had a single false positive with Google Home.
Google Home for Home Security
Let’s get to the important question: Can Google Home enhance your home’s security? Like Amazon’s Alexa, Google Home can’t create a more secure home on its own. You’ll need to connect it to compatible devices using your Google Home app.
As Echo has been around longer, the device does offer more integrations. However, Google is quickly catching up. Initially, Google Home worked with Nest Thermostat, IFTTT, SmartThings, Philips Hue, WeMo and a few other random devices. But over time, this list has grown to include several useful home security integrations.
Alarm.com and Frontpoint Home Security
The easiest way to enhance your home’s security using Google Home is to connect it directly to your security system. Unveiled at Google I/O, Alarm.com now supports actions for Google Home. Using your voice, you can ask Alarm.com to lock your doors, arm your security system, adjust your thermostat, and more. To add even more security to the process, the action supports a home security PIN that is required if you choose to disarm your system or unlock your doors using your voice.
The integration between Alarm.com and Google Home means that Google Home now works with numerous home security systems including Frontpoint Security, LiveWatch, Link Interactive, and more.
Google Home’s integration with SmartThings allows you to control connected devices. The focus of the integration is smart home control, but you can also use it to strengthen your home’s security. For example, you can ask Google Home to turn on all your connected lights if you hear a sound. Unfortunately, the integration is still limited to a few parlor tricks. As of now, you can’t connect SmartThings’ sensors to Google Home, so it’s not yet possible to arm your sensors with your voice.
For home security, IFTTT is a winner. IFTTT lets you trigger smart home devices using voice commands. The only problem is that you need to say the commands correctly word-for-word, similar to how Alexa interacts with Alexa Skills. If you can remember the trigger phrase needed, you will be able to interact with multiple smart devices, home security cameras, and even internet-backed services. With the right trigger phrase you can:
- Turn on your lights.
- Trigger a siren.
- Lock your doors.
Making Emergency Calls
Through IFTTT, you can also trigger a phone call using your voice, but IFTTT is limited to one phone number. If you want to use Google Home to contact loved ones in an emergency, check out Ask My Buddy.
Ask My Buddy was created as a skill for Amazon Alexa, but the free service can also work with Google Home. While not a substitute for 9-1-1, My Buddy will allow you to dial up to five emergency contacts using your voice. You can contact one person, or you can choose to alert all of your emergency contacts at the same time. In addition to sending out an emergency voice alert, Ask My Buddy will simultaneously send an email and a text message.
My Buddy is enabled through the Google Home app. From the app, you can create a Shortcut to Ask My Buddy. To create a Shortcut, go to the app and tap on the Menu (the three stacked lines). Under Services select Shortcuts and then tap on the + button. The first field will ask you to type out or say the trigger phrase or phrases you want to use. Take note that you can set more than one phrase to trigger a single action. For example, you can say “help me” and “call for help” as shortcuts for Ask My Buddy. After setting your trigger phrase/s. Whenever you say “Hey, Google, help me/call for help”, Google Home will trigger your selected action. Take note that if you want your Shortcuts to work for multiple users, you will have to create the same Shortcut on every user’s app.
Finally, Google Home can also make calls without help from other devices or software. The ability to make voice calls is limited to outgoing calls, but in true Google fashion, it’s smart. The device can adjust who it calls based upon whose voice it hears. For example, if you ask it to call your mom, it will call your mom. If your son asks it to call his mom, it will call his mom. Using your voice, you can make a call by contact name, phone number, or even call a local business. And while it can’t call 9-1-1, there is no reason why you can’t use the device to call your local police department. However, be forewarned that the device currently doesn’t have caller I.D. so if you call the police department, it will show up as caller unknown so check with your local heroes first to see how they handle unknown callers. Google has plans to roll out caller I.D. later this year.
August was the first smart lock brand to work with Google Home. Although Google supports both the 1st and 2nd gen smart locks, you’ll need an August Connect Wi-Fi bridge to make this integration work. If you don’t own an August Connect bridge yet, you can get one here. As an alternative, you can use the August Doorbell Camera as a bridge. Per a conversation I had with the August team, using the Doorbell Camera as a bridge is not something they have tested extensively, but they do feel that it will work.
You should also note that August isn’t listed as a Google Home compatible device. Instead, you can find August under supported services.
For now, you can only ask Google Home to list all of your connected August locks, lock your doors, or check the status of your locks. For security reasons, you can’t unlock your doors using Google Home.
Google Home also works with Vivint, a company that provides professional security monitoring. The integration allows Vivint Sky panel users to check the weather, lock connected door locks, control their Vivint Element thermostat, and arm their security system.
Unlike Alarm.com, Google Home can’t disarm your Vivint alarm system or unlock your door, but I suspect that they too will launch a security PIN in the future.
With a paid monitoring plan, Scout users can connect their security system to Google Home. Via the integration, you can arm and disarm your system check your alarm status including its current mode.
Google Home also welcomes Wink. Unfortunately, as of now, there’s little value to this integration as it only allows users to voice control Wink-connected switches, lights, plugs, and thermostats. When it comes to real security features, the Wink + Google Home partnership is still lacking.
If you’re a Wink user, don’t fret. Wink is one of the friendliest platforms to date, and we’re confident that their partnership with Google Home will eventually grow.
Similar to Wink, SmartThings, and WeMo, TP-Link now integrates with Google Home. And like those integrations already mentioned, it only goes as far as voice-controlled lights, switches, and plugs.
|Smart Lights & Plugs||Deako, D-Link, Emberlight, Geeni, Hive Home, iDevices, iHome Control, Ikea Trådfri, Insignia, LeGrand, Leviton, LIFX, Lutron Caseta, Nanoleaf, OSRAM, Philips Hue, Plum (Coming Soon), Switchmate Bright Smart Switch, TP-Link, WeMo Plugs|
|Smart Home Systems||Control4, D-Link Connected Home, HomeSeer, iDevices, Iris, LightWave, Logitech Harmony Hub, Smartika, SmartThings, Wink|
|Smart Thermostats||First Alert Onelink, Nest Thermostat, Honeywell Lyric Round, Lyric T5 and Lyric T6 Pro, Honeywell Total Connect Comfort, Sensibo|
|Home Security Systems||Alarm.com, AlarmForce, Frontpoint, Iris, Scout Alarm, Vivint|
|Security Cameras||Chk-In Cam, Ring|
|Smart Smoke/CO Detectors||First Alert Onelink|
|Cars and Car Accessories||Hyundai, Chrysler 300, and Mercedes all Free. Chamberlain is $10 per year|
|Other||Ask My Buddy, Artik Cloud, Awair, FireBoard, Frigidaire, IFTTT, iRobot, Nexx Garage, Nubryte, Rachio, Samsung Artik Cloud, Stringify, Voice UPB, Zoma|
HomePod vs. Google Home vs. Amazon Echo
|Google Home||Amazon Echo||Echo Dot||HomePod|
|Microphone||Far-Field Microphones||Far-Field Microphones||Far-Field Microphones||Far-Field Microphones|
|Speaker||High-Excursion Speaker||360-Degree Omni-Directional Speaker||Lower Quality Speaker||High-Excursion Woofer + 7 Beam-Forming Tweeters|
|Dimensions||5.62” (height) x 3.79” (width) x 3.79” (depth)||9.3” (height) x 3.3” (width) x 3.3” (depth)||1.3″ (height) x 3.3″ (width) x 3.3″ (depth)||6.8″ (height) x 5.6″
|Play Music From||Deezer, Spotify, iHeartRadio, Google Play Music, Pandora, TuneIn, YouTube Music, Musixmatch, Napster, Saavn, 7digital||Amazon Music Unlimited, Amazon My Music, Spotify, iHeartRadio, Pandora, TuneIn, SiriusXM||Amazon Music Unlimited, Amazon My Music, Spotify, iHeartRadio, Pandora, TuneIn, SiriusXM||Apple Music|
|Stream From Your Phone||Yes, via Phone Mirroring, Bluetooth, or Chromecast. Also Philips, Sony, Toshiba, VIZIO, and more||Yes, via Bluetooth||Yes, via Bluetooth|
|Stream From Bluetooth Devices|
|Wake Word||“Okay, Google” “Hey Google”, or “Okay, Boo Boo”||“Alexa”, “Amazon”, or “Echo”||“Alexa”, “Amazon”, or “Echo”||“Hey, Siri”|
|Calendar, Weather, Traffic|
|Shopping List:||Yes, and can order from Google Express Retailers including Costco, Whole Foods, Walgreens, PetSmart, Walmart, and Bed Bath & Beyond if you live in an area where Google’s delivery service is offered.||Yes, and can order from Amazon.||Yes, and can order from Amazon.|
|Control Smart Home:|
|Questions:||Contextual Conversations||Working Toward Contextual Conversations||Working Toward Contextual Conversations||Natural Language + Deeper Understanding of Music-Related Questions|
|Timers and Reminders||Timers Only|
|Intercom (Room-to-Room Calling):|
|Users:||Supports six users. Automatically swaps between accounts.||Supports Households. Must ask Alexa to switch accounts.||Supports Households. Must ask Alexa to switch accounts.||Unknown|
Base: Interchangeable (Silver, Black, White, Blue, Purple, etc.)
|Black, White||Black, White, Optional Skins Sold Separately||White, Space Gray|
|Where to Buy||Visit Site||Visit Site||Visit Site||Visit Site|
In my opinion, Google Assist beats Alexa with its ability to follow contextual conversations and Google Search, it also has more personality. However, not to be left behind, Alexa is currently working on the ability to engage in contextual conversations, and it works with more smart home devices. Also, Alexa offers more assistant skills like reminders, something Google Home is not yet capable of.
If interested, you can order Google Home for $129. The body comes in white with a slate fabric base, but the base is interchangeable (black, white, rose gold, purple, blue, and other colors). You can purchase new bases from the Google Store.
Last Updated 8/18/2017
Read Previous Updates
8/10/2017 Updated post hands-on testing
7/14/2017 Updated with Calling Information and Bluetooth Info
5/17/2017 Added Alarm.com
5/13/2017 Updated with Scout Alarm